Affiliate Marketing guide

Choosing Affiliate Programs: Commissions, Cookies and Payouts

Beginner11 min readUpdated November 2026

Written by Shawn Shellenbarger · selling online since 1997

How to compare programs the way a business owner would: commission structure, cookie length, reversal rates, payout terms and the red flags that mean walk away.

What you will take away

  • Recurring and tiered commissions beat one-time payouts on cheap products.
  • A 24-hour cookie and a 30-day cookie are not the same business.
  • Two or three programs in one niche is plenty.

Four commission structures

Almost every program you will be offered fits one of these.

  • One-time: a flat percentage or fee per sale. Simple, and best for physical products.
  • Recurring: a percentage every month the customer stays. The best model if you can find it, because your work compounds.
  • CPA or per lead: a fixed amount for a form fill or trial signup. Predictable, and easy to compare across programs.
  • Tiered: a higher percentage as your volume grows. Worth asking for once you are sending real traffic.

Reading a program's real numbers

Ask for these before you write a single word about a product.

  • EPC: what an average click earns. Ask what traffic that figure came from.
  • Reversal rate: the share of commissions clawed back for refunds and chargebacks. 15% is normal. 40% is a warning.
  • Payout schedule and minimum: monthly with a $50 floor is workable. Quarterly with a $500 floor ties up your cash.
  • Attribution rules: last click, first click, or last affiliate wins. Know which game you are playing.

Where to find programs worth joining

There are three places, and they differ in how much control you get.

  • Direct: the company's own affiliate page. Usually the best commission and the best data, and the hardest to get into without a track record.
  • Networks: large platforms that manage many merchants. One application covers dozens of programs and payments arrive from one place.
  • Marketplaces and directories: fastest to browse, slowest to trust. Useful for finding a niche, not for building a business on.

Red flags worth walking away from

I have passed on programs that looked great on the surface. These are the things that made me walk.

  • The only way to make money is recruiting other people.
  • No product you can point to, or a product nobody would buy without the pitch.
  • Terms that can change without notice, or commissions that quietly stop appearing.
  • Pressure to buy the program's own training before you are allowed to promote it.

Reading the terms without a lawyer

You do not need to read every clause. You need four of them, and if any one is missing or vague, ask in writing before you send traffic.

A program that will not answer a simple question about its own terms will not be easy to collect from later.

  • The cookie window, and whether it resets on a return visit.
  • What counts as a qualified sale, especially for trials and subscriptions.
  • The refund and chargeback policy, since reversed orders reverse your commission too.
  • The termination clause: can they drop you without notice, and what happens to commissions you already earned?

How many programs is too many

Two or three, in one niche. Enough to compare honestly, few enough that you actually learn the audience. A page about email software for ecommerce stores can recommend three tools credibly. A page recommending thirty tools from thirty industries helps nobody, and converts like it.

Once one program is consistently profitable, adding a second in the same niche is usually a better use of time than chasing a brand new market.

When to ask for a better rate

Most affiliates never ask, and most programs have room. Ask when you can show a number: last month's sales, the traffic source, and the fact that you are deciding where to send it next.

The best moment is after a strong month, not before you start. A short email with three numbers, the volume you sent, the conversion rate, and what you are considering adding, gets a better answer than a paragraph about how much you like the product.

Questions people ask me

What is a good EPC in affiliate marketing?

It depends on the price of the product, so only compare within a niche. A $10 EPC is excellent on a $50 product and weak on a $2,000 one. What you actually want is an EPC high enough to cover your cost per click with margin left over, and you cannot know that until you have run a hundred clicks of your own.

What does the cookie window mean for me as an affiliate?

It is the number of days you get credit after someone clicks your link. A 30-day window means a visitor who buys three weeks later still pays you. If the product has a long consideration cycle, a short window quietly erases most of your commissions.

Can an affiliate program refuse to pay me?

Yes, if you break its terms, send incentivized or fraudulent traffic, or if the merchant goes out of business. Reputable networks pay on schedule and show you the reversal detail. Treat a program that misses a payment date twice as a program to leave.

Should I join a network or apply to programs directly?

Apply directly once you have traffic and a relationship worth having, because the commission is usually better. Use a network while you are testing, because one application gets you into dozens of programs with one payout schedule to manage.

Paid placements

Ready to buy traffic for your affiliate offers?

Search, email and social are only part of the picture. Buying placements on content sites is how established affiliates add volume, and the course I recommend for that channel is the Native Ads Master Class by Tom Bell and David Ford. My review covers all 14 modules, the $997 price and who should skip it.

Read my Native Ads Mastery review

Want a second set of eyes on your account?

Send me where you are stuck and I will tell you the first two or three things I would change.

Book a Call With Me

Link to this page